Back to Blogs

Nordic Nexuz

Cold Email

What is a good cold email reply rate?

What is a good cold email reply rate?

What is a good cold email reply rate?

Recent cold email reply rate studies put typical senders between 0.45% and 3.43%. How to compare your rate, count positive replies and fix a rate that is low.

Recent cold email reply rate studies put typical senders between 0.45% and 3.43%. How to compare your rate, count positive replies and fix a rate that is low.

By

Kasper Hallberg

·

Published

·

4

min read

The short version

There is no single good cold email reply rate, because benchmarks measure different senders in different ways. Recent large studies from 2025 and 2026 put typical senders between 0.45% and 3.43%. Track positive replies per send, and check bounces and the list before you rewrite the copy.

Contents

    A good cold email reply rate is one you compare with a benchmark built the same way as your own numbers. Published figures for typical senders run from under half a percent to over three percent. The studies measure different senders and count in different ways, so a rate that looks weak against one can look normal against another. Before you decide a campaign is failing, check what the benchmark divides by, which replies it counts and whose campaigns it covers.

    Why cold email reply rate benchmarks disagree

    Belkins analysed 7.5 million cold emails sent in 2025 and found a reply rate of 0.45%, counting unique replies against emails sent and leaving out auto-replies and bounces. Smartlead looked at more than 850 million emails from senders with at least 500 sends and puts the median sender at 0.74%, about one reply per 135 people contacted. Its top 10% of senders reach 2.63%. Instantly reports an average of 3.43%, counting every reply, follow-ups included, against emails sent. Apollo calls 3% to 6% healthy for broad B2B campaigns.

    These figures describe different senders as well as different methods. Belkins' numbers come from campaigns it ran for its clients, while Instantly and Smartlead report on whoever sends through their tools. The denominator matters too. For the same campaign, a rate per email sent comes out lower than a rate per person contacted, because one person receives several emails in a sequence. Belkins says its earlier studies divided by the people who opened, which gave higher figures, and that the two methods measure different things. Apollo cites one of those earlier Belkins averages, 5.8% for 2024, next to its own healthy range.

    Bar chart of four published cold email reply rate figures, 0.45% from Belkins per email sent in 2025, 0.74% for the Smartlead median per person contacted, 2.63% for the Smartlead top 10% and 3.43% for the Instantly average per email sent

    Count positive replies, not every reply

    A total reply rate includes people who say no, ask to be removed or write back to say they are the wrong person. Apollo cites a Sales.co analysis of over 2 million emails where the average reply rate was 2.09% and 14.1% of replies were positive. Most published benchmarks do not split positive replies out at all. That makes them a weak guide to how many sales conversations a campaign will start.

    Our own data gives one positive-reply figure. On one campaign of 34,000 cold emails we saw one positive reply for every 86 sends, about 1.2% of emails sent. That is a single campaign, not a benchmark for your market, but it shows the unit worth tracking. Write your result as one positive reply per so many sends, because that tells you how many emails one interested reply costs. Track it per segment, as our guide to planning cold email for a niche market explains, so a strong segment cannot hide a weak one.

    Grid of 86 envelopes with one highlighted, one positive reply in 86 sends from one campaign of 34,000 cold emails

    Is a low reply rate normal or a sign the setup is broken?

    Teams that run cold email themselves, with contacts from a sales database and copy written with AI, sometimes ask whether a low rate is normal. Start with Smartlead's spread, which counts per person contacted. Its median is 0.74% and its bottom quarter sits at 0.37%, so a rate in that band is common across its senders. Apollo treats a rate under 3% as a sign of a targeting or deliverability problem. Against Smartlead's spread most senders would fail that test, so read it as a warning sign for broad lists rather than a hard line. Bounces are the other early signal. Smartlead's median bounce rate is 1.54%, and Instantly recommends staying under 2%.

    Then read the first email on its own. In Smartlead's data the first email gets one reply per 85 people contacted and the seventh gets one per 303, so a sequence that only produces replies in late follow-ups points to a weak opener. Apollo notes that deliverability problems can look like messaging problems, so check inbox placement before you rewrite the copy. Apollo also warns that generic AI-written personalization can hurt deliverability, which matters when the copy came out of a prompt with no real detail about the reader.

    What moves the reply rate

    Who you reach changes the rate a lot. Belkins found that founders and owners replied at 0.57% and VPs at 0.32%. Companies with up to 10 employees replied at 0.72%, against 0.22% for companies with 10,000 or more. A list pulled from a database by job title alone can end up weighted toward the groups that reply least. Our guide to the lead sourcing priorities for cold email goes deeper on list quality.

    Where and when you send shifts the numbers as well. In the same Belkins data, emails to the United States replied at 0.51% and emails to the United Kingdom at 0.48%, while Denmark reached 0.73% and Poland 1.43%. Sends in the morning replied at 0.54%, against 0.40% for sends late in the evening. A campaign aimed at one country is best compared with that country's figure where a study reports one, and a change of send time is a cheap test before a rewrite.

    Length and the shape of the sequence matter too. Smartlead saw one reply per 68 people contacted for emails under 50 words, against one per 97 for emails of 100 to 149 words. Instantly found that 58% of replies come from the first step and 42% from follow-ups, so follow-ups earn their place even though the opener carries most of the weight. Varying the wording across a large send also keeps a sequence from reading like a template, which our guide to spintax in cold email explains.

    Diagram of the order to fix a low reply rate, deliverability first, then the list, then the first email on its own rate, then the follow-ups that bring in a large share of replies

    How to set your own reply rate benchmark

    After the first few hundred sends, write down your rate per person contacted, your positive replies and your bounce rate. Compare the first number with Smartlead's spread and the positive replies with your own past campaigns, not with a headline average built on a different method. Then change one thing at a time, in the order above, and give each change enough sends to read. A rate that stays low while bounces stay clean points you to the list and the first email, in that order.

    If you want a second opinion on your reply numbers, book a call with Nordic Nexuz.

    Cold Email

    Reply Rate

    Benchmarks

    Deliverability

    B2B Outbound

    Written by

    Kasper Hallberg

    Co-founder, Nordic Nexuz

    Builds the cold email systems that book sales calls for B2B companies, paid on revenue share.

    Want warm leads booked for you?

    We find the leads, write the emails and book the calls, all on a revenue share model. You show up and close.

    Book your strategy call

    Keep reading

    Get 38 Proven Cold Email Templates That Work in Any Industry

    Get 38 Proven Cold Email Templates That Work in Any Industry

    Get 38 Proven Cold Email Templates That Work in Any Industry

    Averages 11% Reply Rate

    We ensure your sales team only speaks with high-potential prospects, allowing you to optimize time and resources towards closing more deals.

    Nordic Nexuz on LinkedIn

    Certified

    Instantly Certified Expert badge
    ClickUp Verified Power User badge
    Make Certified Partner badge
    Agency Partner badge
    PlusVibe Certified Power User badge
    AI Ark Expert badge
    Clay University Automated Inbound certification badge
    Maildoso Partner 2026 badge
    Clay University Automated Outbound certification badge

    ©2026 Nordic Nexuz. All rights reserved

    We ensure your sales team only speaks with high-potential prospects, allowing you to optimize time and resources towards closing more deals.


    Nordic Nexuz on LinkedIn

    Certified

    Instantly Certified Expert badge
    ClickUp Verified Power User badge
    Make Certified Partner badge
    Agency Partner badge
    PlusVibe Certified Power User badge
    AI Ark Expert badge
    Clay University Automated Inbound certification badge
    Maildoso Partner 2026 badge
    Clay University Automated Outbound certification badge

    ©2026 Nordic Nexuz. All rights reserved

    We ensure your sales team only speaks with high-potential prospects, allowing you to optimize time and resources towards closing more deals.


    Nordic Nexuz on LinkedIn

    Certified

    Instantly Certified Expert badge
    ClickUp Verified Power User badge
    Make Certified Partner badge
    Agency Partner badge
    PlusVibe Certified Power User badge
    AI Ark Expert badge
    Clay University Automated Inbound certification badge
    Maildoso Partner 2026 badge
    Clay University Automated Outbound certification badge

    ©2026 Nordic Nexuz. All rights reserved